Living with pain is a challenge no one should face alone. It is even more frustrating when that pain stems from an incident that happened months or years ago. You may feel like the opportunity to seek justice has passed, but that is not always the case.
The question of whether you can sue for an old injury is complex, and the answer depends heavily on the specific details of your situation. Understanding your rights begins with understanding the legal timelines that govern personal injury claims in New York.
Many people find themselves in this difficult position for various reasons.
- A nagging pain from a car accident on the Belt Parkway finally becomes debilitating.
- A doctor discovers a surgical error from a procedure that took place years ago.
- A seemingly minor slip and fall at a Brooklyn shop leads to a degenerative condition diagnosed much later.
If you are dealing with the delayed consequences of someone else’s negligence, know you are not out of options. The path forward requires a careful look at the facts, the evidence, and the laws designed to protect people just like you. In such situations, contact a personal injury lawyer in White Plains today.
Schedule a Free Case Evaluation
The Clock is Ticking: How New York’s Statute of Limitations Affects Suing for an Old Injury
The most significant hurdle in any personal injury case is the statute of limitations. This is a legal term for a strict deadline set by law that dictates how long you have to file a lawsuit after an incident occurs.
If you miss this deadline, you generally lose your right to sue, no matter how strong your case might be. Think of it as an expiration date for your legal claim.
In New York, these deadlines vary depending on the type of injury and how it happened.
- General Personal Injury: For most personal injury cases, such as those arising from car accidents, construction site incidents, or slip and falls, you typically have three years from the date of the incident to file a lawsuit.
- Medical Malpractice: Claims against doctors, hospitals, or other medical providers generally have a shorter deadline. You usually have two and a half years (30 months) from the date the malpractice occurred or from the end of a continuous course of treatment for that condition.
- Wrongful Death: If someone’s negligence caused a loved one’s death, the family typically has two years from the date of death to file a wrongful death lawsuit.
These time limits seem straightforward, but the law recognizes that life is not always so simple. What happens if you did not know you were injured right away? This is where an important exception can make all the difference.
When the Clock Starts Later: The Discovery Rule and Your Past Injury Claim
The "discovery rule" is a critical exception to the standard statute of limitations. In certain situations, the legal clock does not start ticking on the day of the incident. Instead, it begins on the day you discovered your injury, or the day you reasonably should have discovered it.
This rule is a lifeline for people who want to sue for an old injury that was hidden or had a delayed onset. This principle is grounded in fairness. The law understands that you cannot be expected to file a lawsuit for an injury you did not know you had.
This is particularly relevant in cases involving hidden medical issues or exposure to harmful substances. Let’s look at a few scenarios where the discovery rule might apply.
- Foreign Objects in Medical Malpractice: If a surgeon accidentally leaves a surgical sponge or medical instrument inside a patient, the victim might not experience symptoms for years.
The statute of limitations clock would likely start ticking when a new X-ray or procedure reveals the foreign object, not on the date of the original surgery.
- Toxic Exposure: A construction worker in Queens might be exposed to asbestos or other toxic chemicals on a job site but only develop a related illness like mesothelioma a decade or more later. The discovery rule would allow the clock to start when the illness is diagnosed and linked to the past exposure.
- Gradual Injuries: Sometimes, an injury from a fall or accident worsens over time. You might have felt some pain initially but did not realize the true extent of the damage until a doctor diagnoses a severe, degenerative condition years later.
Applying the discovery rule requires a careful investigation to establish what you knew and when you knew it. It is a complex legal argument that hinges on proving your discovery of the injury was timely and reasonable under the circumstances.
What if a New Accident Worsens a Past Injury?
Life is unpredictable, and sometimes a new incident can re-aggravate a pre-existing condition. For example, imagine you injured your back in a fall at a Nassau County construction site five years ago.
You recovered but always had a weak spot. Then, you are rear-ended in a minor car accident, and the impact causes a severe herniated disc in that same weakened area. The at-fault driver in the new accident is generally responsible for the full extent of the harm they caused, even if your body was more susceptible to injury.
This is often referred to as the "eggshell plaintiff" rule. Simply, it means the negligent party must take the victim as they find them. The fact that you were already vulnerable does not excuse the person who caused the new or worsened injury.
If you find yourself in this situation, there are a few key steps to protecting your rights.
- Seek Immediate Medical Attention: Get a thorough medical evaluation after the new accident. Be completely honest with your doctor about your old injury and the new symptoms you are experiencing.
- Establish a Clear Link: Your medical providers will play a vital role in connecting the new accident to the worsening of your condition. Their reports will need to clearly distinguish between your baseline condition before the second accident and the new level of injury and pain after it.
- Gather All Medical Records: It is essential to collect your medical records from both before and after the new incident. These documents create a timeline and help demonstrate how the recent event significantly changed your health and quality of life.
Pursuing a claim for an aggravated injury requires showing exactly how the new incident made things worse. This often involves detailed medical evidence and a clear narrative of your health journey.
Possible Challenges When You Sue for an Old Injury
Even with the discovery rule, suing for an old injury comes with unique challenges. The passage of time can make it harder to build a strong case. Being aware of these potential obstacles is the first step in overcoming them.
A significant amount of time passing can create hurdles that must be carefully navigated.
- Faded Memories and Lost Witnesses: Witnesses move, their memories fade, and their contact information can become outdated. Locating people who saw what happened years ago can be a difficult task.
- Missing Evidence: Physical evidence from the scene, such as a broken step or a faulty piece of equipment, is likely long gone. Similarly, official reports or company records may have been discarded or destroyed over time.
- Proving Causation: The other side’s insurance company will almost certainly argue that another event, a degenerative condition, or simply the passage of time, is the true cause of your current pain, not the original incident. The longer the gap between the event and the lawsuit, the more aggressively they will make this argument.
These challenges are not necessarily insurmountable, but they highlight the need for a thorough and meticulous approach to gathering every piece of available information.
Building Your Case: The Power of Records in a Past Injury Claim
Documentation becomes your most powerful tool when time is not on your side. Since physical evidence and witness memories may be weak, a strong paper trail can bridge the gap and connect your medical problems to the original incident.
Your ability to pursue compensation often rests on the quality and completeness of your records. Think of yourself as an archivist of your own history. Every document helps paint a clearer picture for others to understand what you have been through.
Your focus should be on creating an undeniable timeline of events.
Here is a list of documents that can be incredibly valuable.
- All Medical Records: This is the most critical category. You will need every record related to the original injury, any treatments you received over the years, and all documents related to your current diagnosis. This includes records from hospitals like NewYork-Presbyterian or Northwell Health, as well as private clinics in Westchester or Suffolk County.
- Incident Reports: Obtaining a copy is essential if you filed a police report after a car crash, an accident report with an employer, or an incident report with a store manager after a fall.
- Photos and Videos: If you happened to take any photos of the scene or your injuries at the time of the original incident, they can be powerful evidence.
- Personal Journals or Notes: Any notes you made over the years about your pain, symptoms, or limitations can help demonstrate the long-term impact of the injury.
- Financial Records: Receipts for medical expenses, records of lost wages, and any other documents showing the financial cost of your injury are also important.
Gathering these documents can be time-consuming, but it is a necessary foundation for exploring your legal options for a past injury.
Finding Clarity for Your Path Ahead
At Queller Fisher, we dedicate personal attention to clients facing serious and complex injury cases. Our team has extensive experience helping people navigate challenging legal circumstances.
We are honest and realistic, giving you a clear understanding of your options so you can make informed decisions for yourself and your family.
We are here to listen to your story and help you find a path forward.
- Our team is available 24/7 to hear about your situation.
- Consultations are always free, and there is no obligation.
- We can meet with you by phone, video, or in person, and we will come to you if your injuries make it difficult to travel.
If an old injury is causing new problems in your life, contact Queller Fisher today. Call us at (212) 406-1700 in New York City or (718) 892-0400 in the White Plains to speak with someone who can help.
Frequently Asked Questions About Old Injury Claims
What is the statute of limitations in New York for a typical personal injury case?
For most personal injury claims, such as those from a car accident or a slip and fall, the general statute of limitations in New York is three years from the date the injury occurred. However, this deadline can change based on the type of case and other specific circumstances.
My doctor just told me that my chronic pain is from a construction accident that happened five years ago. Is it too late to file a claim?
It may not be too late. This is a classic example of where the "discovery rule" could apply. The legal deadline might begin from the date of your diagnosis, not the date of the accident. The viability of your case would depend on proving that you could not have reasonably discovered the full extent of your injury any sooner.
What happens if I cannot find any of my old medical records from the original injury?
While missing records present a challenge, it does not automatically end your case. There may be other ways to establish the timeline of your injury, such as through witness testimony, pharmacy records showing old prescriptions, or notes from subsequent doctor visits that reference the original incident. A thorough investigation can often uncover documents you thought were lost.
I had a pre-existing back condition before my recent car accident. Can I still receive compensation?
Yes. Under the "eggshell plaintiff" rule, the person responsible for the new accident is liable for any aggravation or worsening of your pre-existing condition. You can seek compensation for the additional harm, pain, and medical treatment you now need because of the new accident. The key is to document how the accident made your condition worse clearly.