Why Do You Need a Lawyer After Suffering Road Rash in a Bicycle Accident?

October 3, 2025 | By Queller, Fisher, Washor, Fuchs & Kool
Why Do You Need a Lawyer After Suffering Road Rash in a Bicycle Accident?

The term "road rash" does not begin to describe the searing pain. It sounds minor, like a playground scrape. But you know the reality. It is the feeling of your skin being forcibly sanded away by the asphalt, embedding gravel, dirt, and glass into raw, bleeding tissue.

After you were struck by a negligent driver, you are now dealing with an intensely painful injury that demands serious medical care. The belief that this is "just a scrape" is a dangerous mistake, one that insurance companies will use to deny you the compensation you need.

Seeking legal guidance for road rash in a bicycle accident is not an overreaction; it is a necessary step to protect yourself from being victimized a second time.

An insurance adjuster may try to dismiss your injury, but a deep abrasion across your back, legs, or arms is a significant medical event with the potential for permanent consequences.

Schedule a Free Case Evaluation

Key takeaways 

  • Road Rash Is a Serious Medical Injury: The term "road rash" is misleading. It is medically classified like a burn, with severe cases destroying all skin layers, requiring surgical procedures, and carrying a high risk of permanent scarring, nerve damage, and infection.
  • The Full Costs Are More Than Skin Deep: A successful claim must account for all damages, including future medical treatments like plastic surgery, lost earning capacity, and significant compensation for the pain and emotional distress caused by permanent disfigurement.
  • A Lawyer Fights Unfair Cyclist Blame: Drivers and their insurance companies almost always try to blame the cyclist. A lawyer is essential for gathering evidence—like video footage and witness statements—to prove the driver’s negligence and protect you from being held responsible for a crash you did not cause.

The True Severity of Road Rash Injuries from a Bicycle Accident

Accident car crash with bicycle on road

Medical professionals classify road rash with the same gravity as burns, grading it in degrees of severity. When you tell an insurance company you have "road rash," they might picture a skinned knee.

A lawyer helps them see the truth by presenting medical evidence of a debilitating injury that requires extensive and costly treatment.

First-degree road rash

This is the most superficial level of injury, but it is still incredibly painful.

  • The top layer of skin (epidermis) is scraped away.
  • Symptoms include redness, minor bleeding, and tenderness.
  • While it typically heals without scarring, the risk of infection is still present if not cleaned properly.

Second-degree road rash

This is a much more serious injury that breaks through the first layer of skin and damages the tissue beneath.

  • Both the epidermis and the second layer of skin (dermis) are damaged.
  • Bleeding is common, and the wound will appear raw and exposed.
  • There is a high risk of foreign debris like gravel and dirt becoming embedded in the wound, requiring medical debridement.
  • This level of injury often leaves permanent scarring or skin discoloration.

Third-degree road rash (avulsion injury)

This is the most severe form, a catastrophic injury that can require surgery and skin grafts.

  • The injury is so deep that it removes all layers of skin, exposing the layer of fat or even muscle and bone underneath.
  • Bleeding is severe, and the pain can be immense.
  • The risk of a life-threatening infection, such as cellulitis or sepsis, is extremely high.
  • Permanent nerve damage, significant scarring, and disfigurement are almost certain without advanced medical intervention like plastic surgery.

An attorney ensures your claim reflects the true medical classification of your injury, not the deceptively mild term the public uses.

Calculating the Full Cost of Your Road Rash Claim

The initial trip to the emergency room is just the beginning. The financial impact of a severe road rash injury unfolds over months or even years.

An attorney identifies and calculates every single category of loss to ensure your settlement covers all of your needs, now and in the future.

Immediate and future medical expenses

Your medical bills go far beyond bandages and antiseptic wipes. A lawyer will compile evidence to demand payment for all necessary treatments.

  • Debridement: This is a painful medical procedure to scrub and remove all foreign material from the wound to prevent infection. It may need to be done under anesthesia.
  • Infection Control: You may need powerful antibiotics, specialized dressings, and frequent follow-up visits to monitor for signs of infection.
  • Pain Management: Severe road rash can cause chronic pain and nerve damage, requiring long-term medication or other pain management therapies.
  • Plastic Surgery and Skin Grafts: For third-degree abrasions, reconstructive surgery may be the only way to close the wound and minimize permanent disfigurement.
  • Scar Revision Therapy: Even after a wound heals, you may need treatments like laser therapy or steroid injections to reduce the appearance and discomfort of scars.

Lost income and diminished earning capacity

A serious road rash injury can make it impossible to work. If you have a physically demanding job in construction or retail, an injury to your arms, legs, or hands can keep you sidelined for weeks.

  • Lost wages: An attorney will gather your pay stubs and employment records to calculate the exact amount of income you have lost.
  • Loss of future earnings: If your injury results in permanent nerve damage or physical limitations that prevent you from returning to your previous job, a lawyer will work with financial and vocational professionals to calculate the income you will lose over the course of your career.

Non-economic damages: Pain, suffering, and emotional distress

Damages & Claim written on wood block

This is where an attorney’s help is most critical. Insurance companies have no formula for the human cost of an injury. A lawyer builds a case to show the real-world impact on your life.

  • Physical pain and suffering: This is compensation for the actual physical pain you endure during your treatment and recovery.
  • Emotional trauma: A violent bicycle accident can cause post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), anxiety, depression, and a new fear of cycling or even being near traffic.
  • Disfigurement and scarring: Permanent scars, especially on visible areas like the face, arms, or legs, can cause significant embarrassment, humiliation, and loss of self-esteem. Your claim must account for this lifelong emotional burden.

The Challenge: Proving the Driver Was at Fault

In nearly every bicycle accident case, the driver’s insurance company will try to blame the cyclist. They will use common, baseless arguments to avoid paying the claim. An attorney’s primary role is to fight back with facts and evidence.

Countering unfair blame

Drivers and their insurers will often make false claims to shift responsibility.

  • "The cyclist came out of nowhere!"
  • "They weren't in the bike lane."
  • "They swerved in front of me."
  • "They were wearing dark clothing and I couldn't see them."

An experienced bicycle accident lawyer knows how to dismantle these defenses by conducting a thorough investigation.

How a Lawyer Gathers Evidence in a Bike Crash

Your attorney will work to build an ironclad case demonstrating the driver’s negligence.

  1. Securing the police report: This report contains the officer’s initial observations, witness information, and sometimes an early determination of fault.
  2. Interviewing witnesses: Independent witnesses who saw the crash can provide unbiased accounts that contradict the driver’s story.
  3. Finding video footage: Your lawyer will canvass the area for surveillance cameras on buildings, traffic cameras, or even doorbell cameras that may have captured the entire incident.
  4. Hiring accident reconstructionists: For serious cases, these professionals can use physics and engineering principles to recreate the accident, proving the driver’s speed, angle of impact, and reaction time.
  5. Using New York traffic law: New York City and New York State have specific laws that protect cyclists. For instance, drivers are required to exercise "due care" to avoid colliding with cyclists and must provide a safe amount of space when passing. A lawyer uses a driver's violation of these statutes as direct evidence of their negligence.

Frequently Asked Questions About Road Rash Bicycle Accidents

Q: Is road rash considered a "serious injury" under New York's No-Fault insurance laws?

A: It can be. To step outside of the No-Fault system and sue a driver directly for pain and suffering, your injury must meet the state's "serious injury" threshold. A third-degree road rash that results in significant disfigurement, a fracture, or a significant limitation of use of a body function or system would almost certainly qualify. A lawyer can assess your medical records to determine if your case meets this threshold.

Q: What if I wasn't in a designated bike lane when the accident happened?

A: This does not automatically make you at fault. In New York, cyclists are generally permitted to use regular traffic lanes and have a right to be on the road. A driver still has a duty to see what is there to be seen and operate their vehicle safely. An attorney can protect you from unfair blame based on your location on the road.

Q: How much does it cost to hire a lawyer for my bicycle accident case?

A: Reputable personal injury law firms work on a contingency fee basis. This means you pay nothing upfront. The law firm covers all the costs of investigating and building your case. They only receive a fee as a percentage of the total settlement or verdict they win for you. If you do not get a recovery, you do not owe them a fee.

Q: Should I talk to the driver's insurance company myself?

A: You should not give any detailed statements to the at-fault driver's insurance adjuster. They are trained to ask leading questions to get you to downplay your injuries or accidentally admit partial fault. You should direct all of their communications to your attorney.

Beyond the Scrapes: Demanding Full Justice for Your Injuries

Dallin M. Fuchs - Personal Injury Attorney
Dallin M. Fuchs - Bicycle Accident Lawyer

Your road rash is not just a scrape. It is a painful, traumatic injury caused by another person’s carelessness. It has disrupted your life, cost you time and money, and may leave you with permanent reminders of the crash.

You have the right to demand that the responsible driver and their insurance company cover every dollar of your losses and compensate you for the pain they have caused. Attempting to do this alone puts you at a severe disadvantage.

The personal injury attorneys at Queller Fisher have spent decades fighting for injured cyclists in New York City and the surrounding areas. We know the tactics insurance companies use to minimize serious injuries like road rash, and we know how to defeat them.

We are dedicated to providing the powerful advocacy you need to secure the outcome you deserve. From our offices in New York City and White Plains, we proudly serve clients in Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, Manhattan, and Staten Island, as well as in Westchester, Nassau, and Suffolk counties.

Do not let an insurance company define the value of your pain. Contact Queller Fisher for a free, confidential case evaluation.

New York City Office: The Woolworth Building, 233 Broadway, 18th Floor, New York, NY 10279
Phone: (212) 406-1700
White Plains Office: 2 Westchester Park Drive, Suite 205, White Plains, NY 10604
Phone: (718) 892-0400

Schedule a Free Case Evaluation