Feeling stuck in an attorney-client relationship that isn’t working is a deeply frustrating and stressful experience. You placed your trust in a legal professional to guide you through one of the most difficult times in your life, and now you may feel ignored, unheard, or uncertain about the direction of your case.
The relationship with your attorney should be a partnership built on clear communication and mutual respect. When that foundation crumbles, exploring your options is a proactive and often necessary step toward protecting your future. Making a change can feel intimidating, but it is often the key to getting your case back on track.
Schedule a Free Case Evaluation
Key Takeaways about Changing Your Lawyer in a Case
- A client generally has the right to change their legal representation at any point during their personal injury case.
- Common reasons for seeking a new attorney include poor communication, a lack of confidence in the lawyer's strategy, or feeling that the case is not receiving adequate attention.
- The process involves reviewing the current retainer agreement, finding a new attorney, and formally notifying the previous lawyer of the change.
- In personal injury cases, switching lawyers does not mean the client has to pay two separate full legal fees; the attorneys typically divide a single fee based on the work each performed.
- A former attorney may place a "lien" on the case, which is a legal claim to a portion of the final settlement or award to cover their work and expenses.
- Switching to a law firm that is a better fit can significantly improve the trajectory and potential outcome of a serious injury claim.
Recognizing the Signs: When Is It Time to Consider a New Lawyer?
It’s completely normal to have questions or feel anxious during a legal proceeding. However, certain patterns of behavior can be red flags, signaling that your current legal representation may not be the right fit for your needs. Trusting your instincts is important. If you consistently feel uneasy or dissatisfied, it may be time to evaluate the relationship.
Common reasons people decide to change lawyers include:
- Lack of Communication: Your calls and emails go unanswered for long periods. You feel left in the dark about important developments and are never quite sure what is happening with your case. A responsive attorney should provide regular updates, even if it's just to say there's no new information.
- Feeling Like Just Another Number: Your lawyer seems unfamiliar with the details of your situation, or you are constantly passed off to paralegals or junior associates who can't answer your substantive questions. This is common in high-volume firms, often called "settlement mills," where personal attention is scarce.
- Disagreements on Case Strategy: You may feel your lawyer is pushing you to accept a low settlement offer without exploring all options, or perhaps they don't seem to be preparing the case with the thoroughness it deserves. You deserve an advocate who shares your goals and is willing to fight for a fair outcome.
- Unprofessional Behavior or Personality Clashes: A simple lack of rapport can hinder the open communication necessary for a strong case. If you don't feel comfortable speaking honestly with your lawyer, or if they are dismissive of your concerns, the relationship is likely not sustainable.
These issues are more than minor annoyances; they can directly impact the strength and value of your personal injury claim. You deserve a legal team that is not only competent but also communicative, respectful, and fully invested in your recovery.
Your Right to Change Legal Representation in New York
In New York, the legal system firmly recognizes that the attorney-client relationship is based on trust and confidence. Because of this, you, the client, have an absolute right to discharge your attorney at any time, for any reason—or even for no reason at all. This principle is a cornerstone of client advocacy, ensuring that you remain in control of your legal destiny.
This right is codified in New York's legal standards. While your former attorney is entitled to be compensated for the work they have already performed, they cannot force you to remain their client. The process is designed to be straightforward, allowing for a smooth transition that protects your interests and keeps your case moving forward.
The focus is always on ensuring you have the representation you feel is best equipped to handle your unique situation, whether it involves a construction accident on a site in the Bronx or a complex medical malpractice claim at a Manhattan hospital.
The Step-by-Step Process to Change Your Lawyer in a Personal Injury Case
Making the switch involves a few clear, manageable steps. While it may seem complicated, a reputable new law firm will handle most of the heavy lifting for you, ensuring the transition is as seamless as possible.
Step 1: Review Your Current Retainer Agreement
Before you make any moves, locate the fee agreement or "retainer agreement" you signed with your current lawyer. This document is a contract that outlines the terms of your relationship. Pay close attention to any clauses related to termination, fees, and expenses.
Most personal injury lawyers work on a contingency fee basis. This means they only get paid a percentage of the money they recover for you. Your agreement will specify this percentage and explain how case-related expenses are handled. Understanding these terms will help you know what to expect regarding payment for the work your first lawyer has already done.
Step 2: Finding and Vetting a New Attorney
Your next step is to research and consult with other personal injury attorneys. This is your opportunity to find a firm that aligns with your needs and expectations. Don't rush this process. You are looking for a true partner who will give your case the personal attention it deserves.
When meeting with potential new lawyers, consider asking the following questions:
- What is your experience with cases like mine (e.g., truck accidents, slip and falls, medical malpractice)?
- How will you communicate with me, and how often can I expect updates?
- Who will be my primary point of contact at the firm?
- What is your firm’s philosophy on taking cases to trial versus settling?
- How do you handle the transition from a previous attorney, including the issue of their legal fees?
These questions will help you gauge their experience, communication style, and overall approach, allowing you to find a team that makes you feel confident and supported.
Step 3: The Formal "Breakup" - Notifying Your Current Lawyer
Once you have chosen your new attorney and signed a retainer agreement with them, the change needs to be made official. Your new lawyer will typically handle this for you. They will send a formal letter to your previous attorney informing them that they have been discharged and that the new firm is now the attorney of record. This term simply means they are the lawyer officially responsible for representing you in court and with the insurance companies.
If you prefer to notify your lawyer yourself, it is best to do so in writing (an email or a certified letter) to create a clear record. Keep the message professional and straightforward. You do not need to provide a long, detailed explanation. A simple statement such as, "This letter is to inform you that I have decided to terminate your services and have retained new legal counsel," is sufficient.
Step 4: The Transition - Transferring Your Case File
After the formal notification, your new attorney will request your complete case file from your former lawyer. This file contains all the important documents related to your claim, including medical records, accident reports, correspondence, and evidence.
Your former attorney has an ethical obligation to turn over the file promptly. Your new legal team will manage this entire process, reviewing all the work that has been done and developing a strategy to move forward effectively.
Understanding Attorney's Fees and Liens When You Switch Lawyers
One of the biggest anxieties people have about changing lawyers is the cost. Many worry they will have to pay two legal fees, but that is not how it works in New York personal injury cases. You will not pay more in total attorney's fees just because you switched firms.
Here’s how it is typically handled:
- A Single Contingency Fee: The total legal fee remains the same percentage of your recovery that you agreed to in your original (and new) retainer agreement. For example, if the standard fee is one-third of the recovery, that is the total amount that will be allocated to legal fees, regardless of how many lawyers worked on the case.
- The Attorney's Lien: Your former lawyer is entitled to payment for the reasonable value of the work they completed and the expenses they covered. To protect this right, they will place an attorney's lien on your case. A lien is a legal claim against any future settlement or verdict. It is not a bill you have to pay out of pocket.
- Dividing the Fee: At the conclusion of your case, your new attorney will resolve the lien with your old attorney. The two lawyers will either agree on a fair division of the single contingency fee, or, if they cannot agree, they will resolve the dispute through a process called arbitration or a court proceeding. This happens between the lawyers and does not involve you or your share of the settlement.
This system ensures that your right to choose your counsel is protected without creating a financial penalty for you. Your new lawyer will handle all negotiations regarding the lien, allowing you to focus on your health and recovery.
Will Changing Lawyers Hurt My Personal Injury Case?
This is a valid and common concern. The fear of causing delays or angering a judge can be paralyzing. However, in most situations, changing to a more dedicated and experienced attorney will ultimately help your case, not hurt it. A fresh perspective from a lawyer who is genuinely invested in your case can uncover new strategies, correct previous missteps, and re-energize the entire legal process.
While the transition may cause a minor initial delay as your new team gets up to speed, this is usually short-lived. A proficient attorney can quickly review the file and resume progress. Courts understand that clients have the right to the counsel of their choice and are generally accommodating of these changes, especially when they occur well before a trial date.
The long-term benefit of having the right advocate in your corner far outweighs the temporary inconvenience of the transition. The most significant damage to a case often comes from staying with an unresponsive or ineffective lawyer out of fear of change.
What to Look for in Your Next Law Firm
As you search for new representation, think about what was missing in your previous attorney-client relationship. This is your chance to find a firm that truly fits your needs. Look for a team that is not a high-volume "mill" but a selective practice that gives each case the deep focus it requires.
You may benefit from a firm known for its thorough preparation and willingness to take complex cases to trial if a fair settlement isn't offered. Consider personal injury attorneys who are well-regarded not just by clients, but also by their peers in the legal community—often, the best firms are the ones that other lawyers refer their most serious and challenging cases to. Personalized attention, a wealth of experience, and a clear, honest communication style are the hallmarks of a firm that can truly make a difference.
FAQs: How Do I Change My Lawyer in a Case?
Here are some answers to other common questions that arise when considering a change in legal representation.
Can I change lawyers if my case is close to trial?
Yes, you can, but it can be more complicated. A judge may be hesitant to allow a change that would significantly delay a scheduled trial. However, if there is a compelling reason for the switch (known as "good cause"), the court will likely permit it. It's crucial to act as quickly as possible if you are considering a change at this late stage.
Will a new lawyer be willing to take over my case?
Reputable lawyers are often willing to take over a promising case that may have been mishandled or neglected. During your consultation, the new attorney will evaluate the work that has already been done and the overall merit of your claim. If they believe they can add value and achieve a better result for you, they will likely be happy to take on your case.
How does changing lawyers affect the timeline of my case?
There may be a brief pause while your new attorney obtains and reviews your file. However, an engaged and proactive new lawyer can often make up for this time and even speed things up by moving the case forward more aggressively than the previous attorney did. Any short-term delay is often a worthwhile trade-off for better long-term representation and results.
A Fresh Start for Your Case Begins with a Conversation
Making the decision to change your lawyer is a powerful step toward taking back control of your legal journey. You deserve an advocate who listens, communicates, and fights relentlessly for your best interests. At Queller, Fisher, Washor, Fuchs & Kool, we understand the trust you place in your legal team, and we honor that by providing dedicated, personalized representation to every client.
If you are feeling lost or unsupported in your current personal injury case, we invite you to speak with us. Our highly regarded attorneys have decades of combined experience and a deep commitment to securing justice for those with serious injuries.
We provide a confidential, no-obligation second opinion on your case, helping you understand your rights and options. Contact us today at (212) 406-1700 or through our online form to learn how our client-focused approach can make a difference for you.